kostas22 wrote:Caldwell is average, but at least he isn't ridiculously error prone like his brother Gary. Murphy is a decent player but not EPL class. Burke plays big in a small league and fails at the top level, because he's not got class, only form. Darren Ambrose had one good season at Crystal Palace and then faded into obscurity again as usual. Zigic and Lovenkrands is an absolutely terrible front duo, they're no good with their feet. Davies and Elliott I won't comment on because I don't know them. Carr is the only rock solid player in that lineup, and Butland and Redmond are the only ones with serious potential. Also, Jonathan Spector is woefully under-utilised at the club because he always plays in bad positions. Playing him at CM was a joke, he should play DM to properly utilise his skills. But, of course, no formation the team plays has such a role for him.
In the Championship that lineup may do fine, but if you get to the EPL and expect that to be good enough, the results won't be pretty...
If that team played any EPL side it would get torn to shreds. Also, it's a slight double standard you criticise Alex McLeish so often, yet Zigic, Burke, Caldwell and Murphy were all brought in under him. I think the Villa/City rivalry is clouding your judgement somewhat...
To be fair to McLeish, he does sign good players, Ben Foster for example, plus loan signings such as Alexander Hleb, Obafemi Martins and of course Joe Hart. But with the exception of goalkeepers he can't utilise players properly to save his life thanks to his horrendous tactics.
However, the Villa/City rivalry is not clouding my judgement. He relegated us in 2007/08, when he took over earlier in that season, we really shouldn't have gone down. And he relegated us in 2010/11 despite winning the cup. McLeish used to play for draws every game, and it cost us as we didn't win enough games, especially in 2007/08. Also, a lot of the time, he insisted on playing Cameron Jerome on his own upfront, despite him being useless virtually all the time, other than one amazing goal against Liverpool. Fair enough, in the 2009/10 season, we had the longest unbeaten run, but that was basically thanks to Joe Hart.