DanielPT wrote:Pointrox wrote:Now that Sebastian Vettel is close to winning his third consecutive title, I've been thinking...
It's been 7 years since Red Bull took Jaguar F1 over to make their own team, and 6 years when they did the same thing with Minardi to form STR.
Red Bull had a great start, with Coulthard being the driving force - he scored RB's first podium. They've been strong in the midfield, and even finished in Top 5 in 2007. Then came the rule changes - and Red Bull's performance has shot through the roof. First win, first 1-2 finish for Vettel-Webber duo and eventually second place in both 2009 WDC and WCC. A year later... you know the rest.
Now let's move back to Scuderia Toro Rosso. Despite having the same strong backing, and using RB's proven cars from last season with some improvements they didn't quite replicate the success of their older brother. The only peak in their performance was Vettel's two year stint, with Valencia 2008 being the best result to date.
Rule changes saw ex-Minardi being in the same place they did before Vettel. Unable to get any closer to Top 5 than 8th position. 2011 was their best post-09 season, with Buemi-Alguersuari being in their prime for the equipment they've had.
I just wonder - what went wrong? How is it possible that those two teams started from relatively the same base level (low-tier team and lots of money) and only one team got the better end of the deal? STR wasn't given enough attention (and still isn't)? Or maybe it's the drivers that cannot match Vettel's talent? What is Toro Rosso nowadays - a place for young talents, or merely Red Bull's storage where they can put their Junior Team drivers in? Have your say, guys.
It's quite simple really and I will answer this with two words while disregarding the difference in budgetary levels: Adrian Newey.
It is more than just Newey, though. When Vettel went from Toro Rosso to Red Bull Racing, he wasn't the only person who was transferred across - a number of Toro Rosso's senior designers were reportedly brought in to bolster Newey's workforce at Red Bull Technology, which predominantly focusses its efforts on the parent team.
In other ways, Toro Rosso is something of an irrelevance to Red Bull Racing now that there are much stricter conditions on transferring technology between teams, although they can and have exchanged some information (James Allen reported that there was considerable amounts of information being exchanged between Red Bull and Toro Rosso in 2011 over the design of their blown diffusers). Whilst Toro Rosso also gave Red Bull an additional vote in WMSC meetings and a little more leverage with the FIA and FOM, their recent deals with FOM over the new Concorde Agreement have given them the leverage they sought in the past, and additionally there is less of a need to train up young drivers in house when you can simply buy a seat for them elsewhere on the grid (as happened with Ricciardo at HRT in 2011).
All in all, being part of Red Bull's team, but being a distinctly secondary consideration, is hurting them - Red Bull have reportedly been trying to sell the team for some time and are therefore unlikely to be worried about trying to drive that team further up the grid when the parent team dominates everything. With the spoils going to the parent team, the junior team has effectively been turned into a talent farm for Red Bull Racing - somewhere where they can train drivers and look for talented designers to draw into the parent team, draining Toro Rosso and leaving it unable to advance up the field.