Live Podcast Race Commentary?

Stuart · Post by **Stuart** » 06 Jan 2010, 17:55

Ladies and Gentlemen,

After the New Years podcast and the amusing discussion regarding a Japanese drivers DVD boxset and having an easter egg etc. I thought how about Enoch and Jamie do a DVD style commentrary of a Grand Prix? Often me and my friends watch a GP together and chat and joke about what's going on. How brilliant would it be to have a live stream of the F1 Rejects guys discussing whats going on as well? Like a live Podcast race commentray? What about being able to email the guys live or Twitter them live? I think it could be pretty funny and insightful... Just like the podcasts are!

I think you should try this Enoch and Jamie, even if only for a couple of races?

What do the people of the forums think?

- Stuart

http://www.stewzer.com
http://twitter.com/stewzer
http://www.facebook.com/stewzer

shinji · Post by **shinji** » 06 Jan 2010, 19:55

I feel like you're talking down to me. That saddens me.

That'd probably be a bit overcomplicated for the amount of listnership it'd get, I'm very happy with the amount of coverage that the podcasts and race reviews give, and I'm not even sure that Jenoch even watch the races live, aren't they on at like 2 in the morning in Australia?

Phoenix · Post by **Phoenix** » 06 Jan 2010, 21:09

I didn't bother entering the links.
I think podcasts are good enough, and J&E perhaps don't want to bother making DVDs and having to send them to everyone of us.

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 06 Jan 2010, 21:24

Much as I would enjoy such a feature, I would likely as not keep forgetting about it and tune into Martin Brundle instead. On top of that, Jamie and Enoch have their own lives to be getting on with, and to give us a regualr podcast, a website and a forum for free, who am I to demand more from our Overlords????????

Stuart · Post by **Stuart** » 06 Jan 2010, 21:58

shinji wrote:I feel like you're talking down to me. That saddens me.

Apologies if it sounds like that. It wasn't my intent. The whole thing was just a thought. I appreciate how much everyone at F1 Rejects does. I just listen. Needless to say you always want more of a good thing

Stuart.

Kuwashima · Post by **Kuwashima** » 07 Jan 2010, 00:36

Hmmm.... nice idea! This is certainly something we might consider doing as a one-off.
For the Australian GP perhaps? But there would need to be some demand....

[Aside: We did actually "live record" our thoughts in bursts through the German GP for later use on the podcast (ie with the aim of replacing our usual analysis with our live thoughts as things happened) but at the end of the race our recordings were accidentally deleted. Very disappointing.]

thehemogoblin · Post by **thehemogoblin** » 07 Jan 2010, 01:28

Kuwashima wrote:Hmmm.... nice idea! This is certainly something we might consider doing as a one-off.
For the Australian GP perhaps? But there would need to be some demand....

[Aside: We did actually "live record" our thoughts in bursts through the German GP for later use on the podcast (ie with the aim of replacing our usual analysis with our live thoughts as things happened) but at the end of the race our recordings were accidentally deleted. Very disappointing.]

I DEMAND IT.

There's your demand.

P_Friesacher · Post by **P_Friesacher** » 07 Jan 2010, 02:37

I like the idea, too. However I have to admit I probably wouldn't listen to it live, I'm just too much of a traditionalist. But a "Live Highlights Show" as part of the regular podcast - that sounds great!

TimmyB · Post by **TimmyB** » 07 Jan 2010, 04:20

I demand it too!

I'd listen for sure.
Especially as the Aus GP is going to be the second race in a momentous season of the return of mediocrity to Formula 1.

RejectSteve · Post by **RejectSteve** » 07 Jan 2010, 06:19

Great ideas all.

TimmyB wrote:I demand it too!

I'd listen for sure.
Especially as the Aus GP is going to be the second race in a momentous season of the return of mediocrity to Formula 1.

Is qualifying televised live in Australia? No mediocrity incapsulation could be complete without "live highlights" of Q1 in Bahrain?

SuperAguri · Post by **SuperAguri** » 07 Jan 2010, 06:53

I demand it too, although I think the Japanese GP would be more apt for a number of Kobayashi reasons...

captainhappy · Post by **captainhappy** » 07 Jan 2010, 07:39

Stuart wrote:Ladies and Gentlemen,

I thought how about Enoch and Jamie do a DVD style commentrary of a Grand Prix? Often me and my friends watch a GP together and chat and joke about what's going on. How brilliant would it be to have a live stream of the F1 Rejects guys discussing whats going on as well? Like a live Podcast race commentray? What about being able to email the guys live or Twitter them live?

.... are you staking out a tree fort near the Brangelina complex in france right now????

Stuey it's a good idea, but you know what they say about too much of a good thing. . . . . Oh, alright I confess! I googled the hell out of EYTL with intent of finding the address to send his family a Christmas present of Roary the racing car. Your stalker heart would be impressed by his photo publishing career!

Disclaimer: (this post heavily influenced by appletons jamaican rum)

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 07 Jan 2010, 09:29

P_Friesacher wrote:I like the idea, too. However I have to admit I probably wouldn't listen to it live, I'm just too much of a traditionalist. But a "Live Highlights Show" as part of the regular podcast - that sounds great!

As I posted earlier, I would probably not remember to tune in live so this would be a brilliant compromise. If the guys are keen and willing to do it, I would love to listen the the edited (or even non-edited - the more the merrier!) highlights as a podcast, while watching again on the BBC iPlayer...!!!!

Phoenix · Post by **Phoenix** » 07 Jan 2010, 11:18

Could work, so I agree too.

CarlosFerreira · Post by **CarlosFerreira** » 07 Jan 2010, 17:46

thehemogoblin wrote:I DEMAND IT.

There's your demand.

In economics, a "demand function" is a measure of "willingness to pay", which makes the whole deal extremely complex. :roll:

Collieafc · Post by **Collieafc** » 07 Jan 2010, 17:52

I think it could work as a one off. However, knowing Sods law, the race Enoch and Jamie choose will unfortunately somehow turn out to be a procession (although if its being done after the race, that wouldnt be an issue)

I can hear it now... "Thats Piquet Jr a little in the way here, a little in the way there, hes in it due to his family, not his skills..."

thehemogoblin · Post by **thehemogoblin** » 07 Jan 2010, 19:10

CarlosFerreira wrote:
thehemogoblin wrote:I DEMAND IT.

There's your demand.

In economics, a "demand function" is a measure of "willingness to pay", which makes the whole deal extremely complex.

Ewwconomics.

CarlosFerreira · Post by **CarlosFerreira** » 07 Jan 2010, 20:20

thehemogoblin wrote:
CarlosFerreira wrote:
thehemogoblin wrote:I DEMAND IT.

There's your demand.

In economics, a "demand function" is a measure of "willingness to pay", which makes the whole deal extremely complex.

Ewwconomics.

No. E-cow-nomics

Post by **DemocalypseNow** » 07 Jan 2010, 20:52

AUSTRALIAN ECOWNOMICS
You have two cows
You promise to pay the Germans money to genetically modify your cows for you
Your cows start producing beer
You pay the Germans with cans of Fosters from the inferior cow

eytl · Post by **eytl** » 07 Jan 2010, 20:53

captainhappy wrote:Oh, alright I confess! I googled the hell out of EYTL with intent of finding the address to send his family a Christmas present of Roary the racing car. Your stalker heart would be impressed by his photo publishing career!

Yes, I make a number of appearances on this internetty-thing in various contexts ...

And yes, I do have a burgeoning second hobby in photography, see the link below in my signature. There are some F1 and A1GP shots which some of you may like.

Plus I can exclusively reveal that, due to timezones, clashing commitments etc., we're looking at maybe doing Malaysia to record a live race coverage.

Post by **DemocalypseNow** » 07 Jan 2010, 20:54

eytl wrote:
captainhappy wrote:Oh, alright I confess! I googled the hell out of EYTL with intent of finding the address to send his family a Christmas present of Roary the racing car. Your stalker heart would be impressed by his photo publishing career!

Yes, I make a number of appearances on this internetty-thing in various contexts ...

And yes, I do have a burgeoning second hobby in photography, see the link below in my signature. There are some F1 and A1GP shots which some of you may like.

Plus I can exclusively reveal that, due to timezones, clashing commitments etc., we're looking at maybe doing Malaysia to record a live race coverage.

Typical...the only Grand Prix I won't be watching live :lol:

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 08 Jan 2010, 11:07

eytl wrote:
captainhappy wrote:Oh, alright I confess! I googled the hell out of EYTL with intent of finding the address to send his family a Christmas present of Roary the racing car. Your stalker heart would be impressed by his photo publishing career!

Yes, I make a number of appearances on this internetty-thing in various contexts ...

And yes, I do have a burgeoning second hobby in photography, see the link below in my signature. There are some F1 and A1GP shots which some of you may like.

Plus I can exclusively reveal that, due to timezones, clashing commitments etc., we're looking at maybe doing Malaysia to record a live race coverage.

Love the photos. And now I know who it is that features in your avatar photo. Hurrah!

Phoenix · Post by **Phoenix** » 08 Jan 2010, 11:49

dr-baker wrote:
eytl wrote:
captainhappy wrote:Oh, alright I confess! I googled the hell out of EYTL with intent of finding the address to send his family a Christmas present of Roary the racing car. Your stalker heart would be impressed by his photo publishing career!

Yes, I make a number of appearances on this internetty-thing in various contexts ...

And yes, I do have a burgeoning second hobby in photography, see the link below in my signature. There are some F1 and A1GP shots which some of you may like.

Plus I can exclusively reveal that, due to timezones, clashing commitments etc., we're looking at maybe doing Malaysia to record a live race coverage.

Love the photos. And now I know who it is that features in your avatar photo. Hurrah!

I watched some months ago a video of a V8 Utes race at Surfers Paradise. It was the last laps, and everyone was bashing frantically one against the other, but it was a more hairy situation considering the lenght of the cars.

Bort · Post by **Bort** » 10 Jan 2010, 22:45

A youtube video after every four or so races with clips of rejectory with commentary would be pretty awesome.
Or just an end of season youtube video wrap-up with all the best bits in it.

TimmyB · Post by **TimmyB** » 11 Jan 2010, 12:29

Bort wrote:A youtube video after every four or so races with clips of rejectory with commentary would be pretty awesome.
Or just an end of season youtube video wrap-up with all the best bits in it.

Well it wouldn't be able to be actual F1 footage because FOM is extra diligent in getting rid of clips of recent F1 races.

Alianora La Canta · Post by **Alianora La Canta** » 11 Jan 2010, 13:10

This is true, but the F1 Rejects team could always re-create the incidents they're talking about after the fact using assorted objects in their houses (possibly even old F1 scale models) after they've decided which commentary items are the gems.

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 11 Jan 2010, 18:07

Alianora La Canta wrote:This is true, but the F1 Rejects team could always re-create the incidents they're talking about after the fact using assorted objects in their houses (possibly even old F1 scale models) after they've decided which commentary items are the gems.

Now THAT would be reject-worthy... is anybody keen to try it?

Phoenix · Post by **Phoenix** » 11 Jan 2010, 19:21

dr-baker wrote:
Alianora La Canta wrote:This is true, but the F1 Rejects team could always re-create the incidents they're talking about after the fact using assorted objects in their houses (possibly even old F1 scale models) after they've decided which commentary items are the gems.

Now THAT would be reject-worthy... is anybody keen to try it?

Me..but I don't know where to send the resulting clips :lol:

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 12 Jan 2010, 17:36

Phoenix wrote:
dr-baker wrote:
Alianora La Canta wrote:This is true, but the F1 Rejects team could always re-create the incidents they're talking about after the fact using assorted objects in their houses (possibly even old F1 scale models) after they've decided which commentary items are the gems.

Now THAT would be reject-worthy... is anybody keen to try it?

Me..but I don't know where to send the resulting clips

I would if I could... but I just wouldn't know where to start. Never posted a youtube clip or anything like that before in my life...

Phoenix · Post by **Phoenix** » 12 Jan 2010, 21:09

dr-baker wrote:I would if I could... but I just wouldn't know where to start. Never posted a youtube clip or anything like that before in my life...

Question is, do you have Hot Wheels cars you could use? :lol:

Post by **DemocalypseNow** » 12 Jan 2010, 21:28

Phoenix wrote:
dr-baker wrote:I would if I could... but I just wouldn't know where to start. Never posted a youtube clip or anything like that before in my life...

Question is, do you have Hot Wheels cars you could use?

I have actual Hot Wheels™ F1 models, of the Ferrari F2001 and McLaren MP4-16 I once got with a McDonalds Happy Meal :lol:

thehemogoblin · Post by **thehemogoblin** » 12 Jan 2010, 22:26

kostas22 wrote:
Phoenix wrote:
dr-baker wrote:I would if I could... but I just wouldn't know where to start. Never posted a youtube clip or anything like that before in my life...

Question is, do you have Hot Wheels cars you could use?

I have actual Hot Wheels™ F1 models, of the Ferrari F2001 and McLaren MP4-16 I once got with a McDonalds Happy Meal

Why did they never do this in America??

Alianora La Canta · Post by **Alianora La Canta** » 12 Jan 2010, 23:17

Now THAT would be reject-worthy... is anybody keen to try it? {dr-baker - 4 posts from bottom of page 1}

I have some very basic recording equipment and two 1:43 scale cars that I know aren't stuck to the display boxes they came in... ...the trouble is that both of them are Saubers (Frentzen 1995 and Fisichella 2004). Also, one of them is a Minichamps model and I have no idea what brand the other one is (I got it because it was the only model I could get with my spare change from lunch, not because of its quality). So unless the Saubers manage to crash into each other in a race, the results would be less than plausible. And even then it would probably be a stop-motion film rather than a true video (unless you don't mind very obvious video director's hands being visible)

But who cares?

I'm not sure if last.fm would allow clips of liveried model cars on its site, otherwise I'd be happy to submit videos there (I have already started doing that with my very infrequently-produced podcasts). YouTube's contributer function is inaccessible to me because I can't even get a Google account due to its stupid set-up. My blog provider only allows 100MB of content (videos eat up space pretty quickly). So posting the results could be a problem... ...but we'll cross that bridge when we get to it.

thehemogoblin · Post by **thehemogoblin** » 12 Jan 2010, 23:31

How can you not get a Google account? It's not like you need a driver's license number or anything...

Waris · Post by **Waris** » 18 Jan 2010, 14:38

thehemogoblin wrote:How can you not get a Google account? It's not like you need a driver's license number or anything...

I wondered this too.
Also, on topic, I think GP reviews might be a bit too much for our good F1 Rejects creators to do, but a season review on DVD (like a bootleg of an actual season review DVD but with the commentary cut out and replaced by Enoch and Jamie's own) would be pretty epic to watch, I think.

Alianora La Canta · Post by **Alianora La Canta** » 19 Jan 2010, 21:28

How can you not get a Google account? It's not like you need a driver's license number or anything... {thehemogoblin - 2 comments ago}

Because you need to be able to read a particularly difficult-to-read CAPTCHA and due to my disability I find it is impossible to read. No CAPTCHA, no account. Basically, Google thinks I'm a machine.

I can manage the simpler CAPTCHAs but not the more complicated ones - Yahoo! is an example of the former, Wordpress is an example of the latter and Blogger is borderline.

Post by **DemocalypseNow** » 19 Jan 2010, 21:32

Alianora La Canta wrote:How can you not get a Google account? It's not like you need a driver's license number or anything... {thehemogoblin - 2 comments ago}

Because you need to be able to read a particularly difficult-to-read CAPTCHA and due to my disability I find it is impossible to read. No CAPTCHA, no account. Basically, Google thinks I'm a machine.

I can manage the simpler CAPTCHAs but not the more complicated ones - Yahoo! is an example of the former, Wordpress is an example of the latter and Blogger is borderline.

How the hell did you manage to sign up to F1 Rejects then?!
I had the same problem - couldn't read the CAPTCHA codes AT ALL and needed Jamie to sort it out for me...which I think has caused the increased levels of spamming over the past few months :oops:

CarlosFerreira · Post by **CarlosFerreira** » 19 Jan 2010, 21:34

Alianora La Canta wrote:How can you not get a Google account? It's not like you need a driver's license number or anything... {thehemogoblin - 2 comments ago}

Because you need to be able to read a particularly difficult-to-read CAPTCHA and due to my disability I find it is impossible to read. No CAPTCHA, no account. Basically, Google thinks I'm a machine.

I can manage the simpler CAPTCHAs but not the more complicated ones - Yahoo! is an example of the former, Wordpress is an example of the latter and Blogger is borderline.

And still you're a training library and a keen reader and blogger. Thumbs up.

P_Friesacher · Post by **P_Friesacher** » 19 Jan 2010, 22:06

When did you last try to create a Google Account? Because Google now seems to have a sound CAPTCHA, which you can unse instead of the text version. I just tried it, and find it rather hard to understand, but perhaps this helps you?

Alianora La Canta · Post by **Alianora La Canta** » 19 Jan 2010, 22:23

How the hell did you manage to sign up to F1 Rejects then?! {kostas22 - 3 posts ago}

It took three attempts, but F1 Rejects has an easier CAPTCHA for me to read than quite a few other places (there are quite a few that are easier, though).