Enforcer wrote:Palmer is so consistently poor that I'm wondering if Renault can't actually run 2 cars to the same level of pace and are focusing on Hulkenberg's car.
Hulkenberg's been in around the points every week and Palmer's propped the grid up. I know Palmer's probably not F1 champion material and isn't as fast as his team-mate, but I'm hard pressed to believe he's this bad.
I do agree that there may be something in the notion that, whilst Palmer isn't great, the difference seems almost a bit too big to be explained by that alone.
It is certainly the case that the Enstone outfit have, traditionally, had a very strict hierarchy within the team, with clearly defined No. 1 and No. 2 drivers. That has, in turn, tended to lead to a quite marked difference in the level of support that a driver gets within the team, with the lead driver getting quite significant privileges over his supporting driver.
We saw that exact situation play out only a few years ago with Grosjean and Kimi, where Kimi was the nominated lead driver and had the bulk of the teams resources directed towards him. That ranged from additional mechanics and engineers supporting his side of the garage through to being given earlier access to upgrade packages - there were many times when Grosjean had to run at least one upgrade package behind Kimi, and sometimes two updates behind him - as well as having bespoke development parts being produced just for Kimi, such as the lengthened wheelbase car that they tried out.
We also saw that, as soon as Lotus reversed their policy and began giving Grosjean more support when Kimi decided he would leave the team, Grosjean's performances improved dramatically - underlining that he might well have been held back quite significantly by the team.
Although that was probably the most extreme example, there have certainly been a number of other drivers, from Fisichella and Trulli to Kovalainen and Piquet Jr who have all complained that they were treated badly by the team and given nowhere near the level of support their teammates did.
Now, given that Renault went out and head hunted Hulkenberg for their team and made it clear that they want to build the long term future of the team around him, he is going to be their primary focus - especially given that Palmer was a long, long way down their list of potential second drivers, to the point where they might almost resent having to keep him on.
It may be that the new regulations aren't suiting him, but it may be that Palmer is also struggling to get to grips with the car because the team might have cut the level of support they have given him and focussed most of their support team on Hulkenberg.
By contrast, since Magnussen didn't really lead the team last year, I wouldn't be surprised if the team didn't concentrate their resources behind him in the same way and gave more even support to their two drivers - if he had a stronger support network behind him last year, that might be why he seemed to do better last year than he has done so far this year.