F1 Rejects Track Designing Competition

novitopoli · Post by **novitopoli** » 12 Sep 2015, 11:55

dr-baker wrote:
novitopoli wrote:Wow! That means I'll have to come up with a challenge. Well...

The Border-Crossing Challenge

As the name states: your circuits must go through two, or more, nations. Some rules:

I assume for the sake of this challenge that England, Scotland and Wales are all the same nation, but Ireland and Ireland are different nations (Northern and Eire)?

Right, England, Scotland and Wales are all the same nation (the United Kingdom), but you can freely use the border between Northern Ireland and Eire, as far as you don't cross any waterways.

I was planning to add a "no microstates" rule, but eventually I decided against it, so, Simtek, that's fine.

Benetton · Post by **Benetton** » 12 Sep 2015, 13:03

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6713277

Italian-Slovenian border.

**EDITED new entry

Post by **Bobby Doorknobs** » 12 Sep 2015, 14:12

dr-baker wrote:
novitopoli wrote:Wow! That means I'll have to come up with a challenge. Well...

The Border-Crossing Challenge

As the name states: your circuits must go through two, or more, nations. Some rules:

I assume for the sake of this challenge that England, Scotland and Wales are all the same nation, but Ireland and Ireland are different nations (Northern and Eire)?

Well, we were partitioned for a reason

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 12 Sep 2015, 15:05

Simtek wrote:
dr-baker wrote:
novitopoli wrote:Wow! That means I'll have to come up with a challenge. Well...

The Border-Crossing Challenge

As the name states: your circuits must go through two, or more, nations. Some rules:

I assume for the sake of this challenge that England, Scotland and Wales are all the same nation, but Ireland and Ireland are different nations (Northern and Eire)?

Well, we were partitioned for a reason

Yeah, but was it a good reason? [/disengage.devil's.advocate.mode]

Post by **Bobby Doorknobs** » 12 Sep 2015, 15:23

dr-baker wrote:Yeah, but was it a good reason? [/disengage.devil's.advocate.mode]

Indeed it was. Not favourable for the majority of Irish nationalists of the time, but better than a potentially more violent civil war than the one we suffered in reality.

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 12 Sep 2015, 15:29

Simtek wrote:
dr-baker wrote:Yeah, but was it a good reason? [/disengage.devil's.advocate.mode]

Indeed it was. Not favourable for the majority of Irish nationalists of the time, but better than a potentially more violent civil war than the one we suffered in reality

I knew it was a good reason really. I was just allowing you to say it wasn't a good reason, it was a great reason!

Just a shame this wasn't much covered in my history lessons at school. I am aware of the effect the IRA had on London, though. Like the fact that it is near impossible to find bins on the Underground (or at least it was for a long time) because they (the IRA) used to keep putting bombs in them.

Will attempt a track in due course (haven't decided which border yet, though!).

Post by **tommykl** » 12 Sep 2015, 16:37

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6712652

Always wanted to do a track around Monschau, and now I have an excuse. Brilliant place, loads of elevation changes.

TheFlyingCaterham · Post by **TheFlyingCaterham** » 12 Sep 2015, 21:12

For the rules stating that the track cannot cross any waterways, are you allowed to cross them if there is alreadya an existing bridge going across it?

If so, I present the Circuito di Citta Vaticano Roma
http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=461921

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 13 Sep 2015, 14:45

Not expecting to win, but here goes.

UncreativeUsername37 · Post by **UncreativeUsername37** » 13 Sep 2015, 19:33

Here's a short one, Haparanda and Tornio. It's a bit FE-style.

Peteroli34 · Post by **Peteroli34** » 13 Sep 2015, 20:37

My attempt crossing the US and Canadian border a total of 4 times

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6713657

tBone · Post by **tBone** » 13 Sep 2015, 21:03

Here's my entry: the Grand Prix of Basque Country on the Circuit of Irun/Hendaye.

Bleu · Post by **Bleu** » 14 Sep 2015, 16:41

A circuit which wouldn't have filled the rules in the 1980s:

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6714218

Klon · Post by **Klon** » 14 Sep 2015, 17:25

BEHOLD! The Genghis Khan Speed Challenge!

Track Map

Inspired by Mongolian culture and history, this is a mad, high-speed dash across the steppe with an invasion into China for that little added spice of authenticity.

novitopoli · Post by **novitopoli** » 16 Sep 2015, 19:15

Two days are gone without any further entries, so I got some tracks to judge.

Simtek - http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=461719
Benetton - http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6713277
tommykl - http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6712652
TheFlyingCaterham - http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=461921
drbaker - http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6713359
UgnCreativeUsergname - Harapanda and Tornio (with an incredibly long URL)
peteroli34 - http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6713657
tBone - http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6713668
Bleu - http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6714218
Klon - http://formularejects.com/uploader/repository/Klon/Other%20Files/TrackDesign_Border.PNG

Results will follow soon.

novitopoli · Post by **novitopoli** » 17 Sep 2015, 21:02

I'll only post the rankings, after having accidentally closed my browser shortly before replying with a wall of text containing comments to every entry. Sorry guys!

10. Klon
9. UgnCreativeUsergname
8. TheFlyingCaterham
7. tBone
6. Benetton
5. dr-baker
4. peteroli34
3. Simtek
2. Bleu
1. tommykl

So, tommykl, that's your turn.

Post by **tommykl** » 17 Sep 2015, 21:53

Right then. I've already done a challenge on my hometown of Sprimont. It's time to do something slightly different. This time, you must create a circuit within the limits of my current place of residence, the City of Oxford. To clarify, this is indeed the famous university city in England, UK.

A couple of restrictions:
-At least 75% of the circuit must be existing roads
-New roads may not cut through buildings
-Track should be between 3 and 9km long
-Cutting through roundabouts and dual carriageways do not count as new roads

Do your best!

Post by **Bobby Doorknobs** » 17 Sep 2015, 22:45

I sure love 90-degree corners!

http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=463504

Peteroli34 · Post by **Peteroli34** » 17 Sep 2015, 23:31

Oxford not the easiest place to design a racetrack but here goes

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6716721

UncreativeUsername37 · Post by **UncreativeUsername37** » 17 Sep 2015, 23:49

Not the most creative road choice, but it has a few cool corners. With one square corner to match each of them....
http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6716736

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 18 Sep 2015, 10:02

Not expecting to win, but here goes: http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6716939

novitopoli · Post by **novitopoli** » 18 Sep 2015, 10:21

My entry: http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6716945

tBone · Post by **tBone** » 20 Sep 2015, 07:50

I've given it a try again: http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6718510

TheFlyingCaterham · Post by **TheFlyingCaterham** » 20 Sep 2015, 09:32

Quite an awkward place to get a "good" layout, but I'll have a go anyways.

http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=464121

Bleu · Post by **Bleu** » 20 Sep 2015, 18:42

Here it goes: http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6718898

Benetton · Post by **Benetton** » 27 Sep 2015, 11:38

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6723764

UncreativeUsername37 · Post by **UncreativeUsername37** » 28 Sep 2015, 18:56

WERE IS JUGING

Post by **tommykl** » 28 Sep 2015, 19:07

UgncreativeUsergname wrote:WERE IS JUGING

JUGE FOGOT BOUT JUGING

Seriously though, had a lot going on. I'm going to prepare a provisional ranking as soon as I can.

Post by **Bobby Doorknobs** » 28 Sep 2015, 19:13

tommykl wrote:
UgncreativeUsergname wrote:WERE IS JUGING

JUGE FOGOT BOUT JUGING

Seriously though, had a lot going on. I'm going to prepare a provisional ranking as soon as I can.

You have 24 hours

Bleu was the last entry before the two-day rule took effect, so I think Benetton's entry is disqualified by my understanding. A shame really as it looked good.

Post by **tommykl** » 28 Sep 2015, 21:21

Not sure if I actually have to post all the links, so I won't for now.

9. Bleu - Almost exclusively 90-degree corners (a recurring theme...), nothing interesting here at all.
8. tBone - Good elevation changes (hard not to get in this part of the city), but far too many 90-degree corners to be really interesting.
7. peteroli34 - Too tight and twisty for my taste, although it incorporates a healthy amount of elevation changes and nice sights. Ultimately too fiddly.
6. TheFlyingCaterham - Not as tight as peteroli34's attempt, but all the 90-degree turns make this track far less interesting than it could be.
5. dr-baker - Very like UgnUser's track, but with more of a stop-start nature that I find less pleasing. Still decent, though.
4. Simtek - Good variety of corners and scenery, though not particularly brilliant for overtaking. You also missed a good opportunity for elevation changes.
3. UgncreativeUsergname - Just as good as peteroli34 with the elevation and sights, but definitely more flowing and pleasant, although it's a shame about that double hairpin on St. Giles...
2. novitopoli - Definitely a layout I'd enjoy driving myself, with the very pretty areas of the City Centre all visited, with brilliant elevation differences and flowing curves. All around great.
1. Benetton - It was really close, but Benetton just edges to the win with a judicious use of 'new' roads, a tour of the many parks around Headington Hill and the crossing of the Cherwell. Also, that kink on Longwall Street is actually a blind corner, as an old building corner constitutes the apex, making it that much more awesome.

UncreativeUsername37 · Post by **UncreativeUsername37** » 29 Sep 2015, 03:05

So to clear up whether Benetton wins, the rule for whether posts after the two-day rule but before the track list or judging count has historically been "do whatever feels right to you". So Benetton does win.

Post by **Bobby Doorknobs** » 06 Oct 2015, 16:52

So yeah, looks like it's now novitopoli's responsibility to set the next challenge.

novitopoli · Post by **novitopoli** » 07 Oct 2015, 10:11

Quite similar to tommykl's last challenge: you'll have to design a circuit within the borders of Bari, Italy (the city I was born in). Rules are similar too:

- The circuit must be max. 10 km long;
- At least half the circuit must consist of existing roads;
- As always, cutting through roundabouts, dual carriageways and similar stuff don't count as "new roads";
- New roads mustn't cut through buildings, nor through the railway;
- When using existing roads, make sure there isn't any level crossing with the railway (tunnels or bridges are OK).

It's harder than it looks.

pi314159 · Post by **pi314159** » 07 Oct 2015, 10:39

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6730434

UncreativeUsername37 · Post by **UncreativeUsername37** » 07 Oct 2015, 19:01

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6730766

Peteroli34 · Post by **Peteroli34** » 07 Oct 2015, 20:58

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6730843

TheFlyingCaterham · Post by **TheFlyingCaterham** » 07 Oct 2015, 21:28

Dug up a circuit which I designed a while ago. Tight and twisty in the bottom section, while fast and flowing in the other.

http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=451336

dr-baker · Post by **dr-baker** » 08 Oct 2015, 12:38

Hoping that this is OK (using some of the roads around the airport): http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6731238

But it does use the Viale Enzo Ferrari!

Post by **tommykl** » 08 Oct 2015, 13:52

http://www.gmap-pedometer.com/?r=6731364

Only barely within the distance limit, but I'm quite happy with it.

Post by **Bobby Doorknobs** » 08 Oct 2015, 23:41

The amount of times I've had to redesign this to meet the existing roads quota...

http://www.mappedometer.com/?maproute=469110