Ataxia wrote:In other news, East Stirlingshire become the first side to be relegated from the Scottish League Two, as they lost to Edinburgh City in the play-offs. It's not too much of a surprise, East Stirling have finished bottom of that league plenty of times in the past 15 years or so.
And thus concludes the story of Scotland's most rejectful League team. Back in the days when the English league had one relegation spot out of Division Four, the gap between the League and the Conference was considered to be so great that the former League team would crush the Conference competition and bounce straight back up, especially as any of the regular Conference sides also had to pass a ground inspection to see if their stadium was up to the job. I suspect that, given the nature of the relegation-promotion play-off between the Highland and Lowland Leagues and the bottom club in the SPFL, it is going to be
painfully difficult for East Stirlingshire ever to be promoted back into the SPFL and I would suspect they'll be stuck in the Lowland League for many years to come.
I might not be anywhere near as interested in football now as I was 20-25 years ago but I always wondered if Scotland would ever allow its non-League clubs to step up somehow - in all that time I can only remember the acceptance of Ross County, Inverness Caledonian Thistle (which used to be two separate clubs), Elgin City, Peterhead, Gretna and Annan Athletic entering the League - and Annan were only brought in because Gretna went bang, whose initial promotion was in turn at the expense of Clydebank.
Meanwhile, to see if it really was easier to return to the English League in t'old days, I'll see how all those clubs fared who were League members for any length of time but who were given a bitter taste of non-League life, ever since the trap door opened from the bottom of Division Four in 1986-87. The 1988-89 season is the first one of these I remember seeing as it happened.
As it turns out there are 33 of them, although some had far more of a lengthy non-League history and only had a brief spell in the League.
OUT, IN AGAIN AND STILL IN:Newport County: relegated to the Conference 1987-88, collapsed February 1989. Restarted as Newport FC (soon to become Newport County again) in 1989-90 in the Hellenic League Premier Division (level 8). Promoted back into the League 2012-13.
Colchester United: relegated to the Conference 1989-90, promoted back into the League 1991-92.
Doncaster Rovers: relegated to the Conference 1997-98, promoted back into the League 2002-03.
Exeter City: relegated to the Conference 2002-03, promoted back to the League 2007-08.
Shrewsbury Town: relegated to the Conference 2002-03, promoted back into the League 2003-04.
Carlisle United: relegated to the Conference 2003-04, promoted back into the League 2004-05.
Cambridge United: relegated to the Conference 2004-05, promoted back into the League 2013-14.
Oxford United: relegated to the Conference 2005-06, promoted back into the League 2009-10.
Mansfield Town: relegated to the Conference 2007-08, promoted back into the League 2012-13.
Luton Town: relegated to the Conference 2008-09, promoted back into the League 2013-14.
Grimsby Town: relegated to the Conference 2009-10, promoted back into the League 2015-16 (even though the 2016-17 season hasn't started yet).
Bristol Rovers: relegated to the Conference 2013-14, promoted back into the League 2014-15.
Cheltenham Town: relegated to the National League 2014-15, promoted back into the League 2015-16 (see also Grimsby).
OUT, THEN IN, THEN OUT AGAIN:Lincoln City: relegated to the Conference 1986-87, promoted back into the League 1987-88. Relegated again 2010-11 and still in the National League.
Darlington: relegated to the Conference 1988-89, promoted back into the League 1989-90. Relegated again 2009-10, collapsed May 2012. Restarted as Darlington 1883 in Northern League Division One (level 9), promoted to National League North 2015-16.
Aldershot: collapsed March 1992. Reformed as Aldershot Town in Isthmian League Division Three (level 9). Promoted back into the League 2007-08; relegated back to the Conference 2012-13.
Halifax Town: relegated to the Conference 1992-93, promoted back into the League 1997-98. Relegated again in 2001-02, collapsed May 2008. Reformed as FC Halifax Town in the Northern Premier League Division One North (level 8); reached the National League again but relegated to National League North in 2015-16.
Hereford United: relegated to the Conference 1996-97, promoted back into the League 2005-06. Relegated again in 2011-12, collapsed December 2014. Reformed as Hereford FC in the Midland League First Division (level 9) 2015-16, immediately promoted to Southern League Division One South & West,
Chester City: relegated to the Conference 1999-2000. promoted back into the League 2003-04. Relegated again 2008-09, collapsed March 2010. Reformed as Chester FC in Northern League Division One North (level 8); now back in the National League.
York City: relegated to the Conference 2003-04, promoted back into the League 2011-12. Relegated again 2015-16.
Torquay United: relegated to the Conference 2006-07, promoted back into the League 2008-09. Relegated again 2013-14.
OUT, IN, OUT (shake it all about) BUT FINALLY IN AGAIN:Barnet: relegated to the Conference 2000-01. Promoted back to the League 2004-05, relegated again in 2012-13, promoted 2014-15.
OUT... AND STILL OUT TO THIS DAYMaidstone United: collapsed August 1992. Reformed as Maidstone Invicta (and later changed the name back in 1997) in Kent County League Division 4 West (level
15!) - manny promotions later, including this season and they're playing in the National League for 2016-17.
Scarborough: relegated to the Conference 1998-99, and again to Conference North 2005-06. Collapsed June 2007, reformed as Scarborough Athletic in Northern Counties East League Division One (level 10); now in Northern Premier League Division One North (level 8).
Kidderminster Harriers: relegated to the Conference 2004-05. Relegated again to National League North 2015-16.
Rushden & Diamonds: relegated to the Conference 2005-06, collapsed June 2011. Reformed as AFC Rushden & Diamonds in 2012-13 United Counties League Division One (level 10), now in Southern League Division One Central (level 8).
Boston United: relegated two divisions to Conference North 2006-07, and two more to Northern Premier League Division One North in 2007-08. Now back up to National League North.
Wrexham: relegated to the Conference 2007-08, and still there.
Stockport County: relegated to the Conference 2010-11, and again to Conference North in 2012-13.
Macclesfield Town: relegated to the Conference 2011-12, and still there.
Tranmere Rovers: relegated to the National League 2014-15, and still there.
Dagenham & Redbridge: relegated to the National League 2015-16, and will kick off in that division in August.
AND A SPECIAL MENTION TO:Wimbledon: had the carpet pulled from under them in 2003-04. Formed AFC Wimbledon, promoted to the League in 2010-11.
It was pointed out that the 2008-09 League One season, Leicester City were playing league matches against Hereford United and Stockport County. Hereford, of course, went to the wall - but Stockport are one of only two clubs I've found (the other being Kidderminster Harriers, who only had a few short years in the League) to have dropped to the sixth tier without having extra financial problems to further force their passage downwards (which Boston United did without collapsing completely). I wonder what happened to Leicester since the dark days of their single season in the third tier...